Last updated: October 2026 · Written by the LawnVibe editorial team.
Sun Joe and Craftsman approach lawn aeration and dethatching from different directions. Sun Joe specialises in walk-behind electric machines, offering several corded dethatchers and scarifiers plus a cordless 24V-X2 model. Craftsman offers one cordless walk-behind dethatcher on its V20 platform, but most of its lawn renovation tools are tow-behind attachments for riding mowers: plug aerators, spike aerators, dethatchers and spreaders.
That makes this Sun Joe vs Craftsman lawn aerator comparison less about which brand is better and more about which approach suits your lawn. Below we compare the walk-behind electric dethatchers head to head, then explain when Craftsman's tow-behind tools make more sense. This comparison is based on published specifications; we did not run hands-on tests.
| # | Product | Best for | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sun Joe AJ805E 15 inch Lawn Dethatcher with Scarifier Reel | Medium lawns near an outlet | Check price |
| 2 | Sun Joe AJ801E Corded Dethatcher and Scarifier | Small lawns on a budget | Check price |
| 3 | Sun Joe 24V-X2-DTS15 Cordless Scarifier and Dethatcher | Cordless dethatching kit | Check price |
| 4 | Craftsman 2x V20 Brushless Lawn Dethatcher and Scarifier | CRAFTSMAN V20 owners | Check price |
| 5 | Craftsman 40 inch Tow Plug Aerator + 40 inch Tow Lawn Dethatcher | Riding mower owners | Check price |
| 6 | Craftsman CMXGZBF7124336 36 inch Tow Spike Aerator | Light aeration before seeding | Check price |
Sun Joe vs Craftsman Lawn Aerator at a Glance
| Feature | Sun Joe | Craftsman |
|---|---|---|
| Walk-behind models | AJ805E, AJ801E, AJ798E corded; 24V-X2-DTS15 cordless | 2x V20 brushless dethatcher/scarifier |
| Power | 12 to 13 amp corded; 48V brushless cordless | Two V20 batteries, brushless |
| Width | About 12.6 to 15 inches | 14 inch deck |
| Collection | 8 gallon and larger bags | 50 litre bag |
| Tow-behind tools | None in this comparison | Plug aerator, spike aerator, dethatcher, spreader |
| Best for | Small to medium lawns | Medium lawns (V20) and large lawns (tow tools) |
Sun Joe AJ805E 15 inch Lawn Dethatcher with Scarifier Reel
Best for: Medium lawns near an outlet
A 13 amp corded dethatcher with a 15 inch path, scarifier reel, depth control and a large removable collection bag.
- Wide 15 inch path
- 13 amp motor
- Scarifier reel
- Corded range
- Bulkier than compact models
Sun Joe AJ801E Corded Dethatcher and Scarifier
Best for: Small lawns on a budget
A 12 amp, 12.6 inch corded dethatcher and scarifier with 5-position height settings and an 8 gallon bag.
- Affordable
- 5 height positions
- Compact storage
- Narrower path
- Corded range
Sun Joe 24V-X2-DTS15 Cordless Scarifier and Dethatcher
Best for: Cordless dethatching kit
Two 24V 4.0Ah batteries deliver 48V to a brushless 600W motor, with a 5-position depth knob.
- Batteries included
- Brushless motor
- 5 depth positions
- Needs both batteries
- Runtime varies with thatch
Craftsman 2x V20 Brushless Lawn Dethatcher and Scarifier
Best for: CRAFTSMAN V20 owners
A cordless brushless dethatcher with a 14 inch deck, 50 litre collection bag, foldable handle and up to about 45 minutes of runtime.
- Large 50 L bag
- Foldable handle
- Brushless motor
- Needs two V20 batteries
- Check kit contents
Craftsman 40 inch Tow Plug Aerator + 40 inch Tow Lawn Dethatcher
Best for: Riding mower owners
A tow-behind bundle with a 40 inch plug aerator using 24 galvanized coring points and a 40 inch dethatcher with automatic raking.
- True core aeration
- Dethatcher included
- Covers ground fast
- Requires a tow vehicle
- Storage space needed
Craftsman CMXGZBF7124336 36 inch Tow Spike Aerator
Best for: Light aeration before seeding
A 36 inch tow spike aerator with 9 galvanized steel discs, a 10-gauge frame, enclosed weight tray and adjustable hitch.
- Sturdy frame
- Adjustable hitch
- Weight tray
- Spike not core
- Requires a tow vehicle
Walk-Behind Dethatchers: Sun Joe Range vs Craftsman V20
Sun Joe gives you more choice. The AJ805E has a 13 amp motor, a 15 inch path with a scarifier blade reel and a large collection bag. The AJ801E and AJ798E are compact 12 amp corded units with a 12.6 inch path and 8 gallon bags, and several models offer 5-position depth control. The cordless 24V-X2-DTS15 uses two 24V 4.0Ah batteries to deliver 48V to a brushless 600W motor, and a tool-only version is available.
Craftsman's 2x V20 brushless dethatcher and scarifier uses two V20 batteries and a brushless motor, with a 14 inch deck, a 50 litre removable collection bag, a foldable handle for storage and a listed runtime of up to about 45 minutes.
The practical difference: if you want an affordable corded machine for a small lawn, Sun Joe has more options. If you already own CRAFTSMAN V20 batteries, the V20 dethatcher fits your existing platform and its large bag means fewer stops to empty. If you want cordless but use neither platform yet, compare the kit costs of the Sun Joe 24V-X2 kit and the Craftsman V20 setup including batteries.
Craftsman's Tow-Behind Option for Bigger Lawns
Where Craftsman pulls ahead is on large lawns with a riding mower. Its 40 inch tow plug aerator uses 24 galvanized coring points listed at up to 3 inches deep, and it is sold in bundles with a 40 inch tow dethatcher or a 110 lb tow broadcast spreader. Its 36 inch tow spike aerator has 9 galvanized discs and an adjustable hitch.
These tools cover far more ground per pass than any walk-behind dethatcher. They also do something Sun Joe's machines do not: true core aeration that pulls plugs of soil, which is what relieves compaction. Kansas State University Research and Extension explains why plugs matter in its guide to aerating your lawn.
Dethatching vs Core Aeration: Know Your Problem
Before choosing, decide what your lawn needs. Thatch is a spongy layer of dead stems and roots between grass and soil. If it is thicker than about half an inch, a dethatcher or scarifier helps. Compaction is hard, dense soil that roots cannot penetrate, often in high-traffic areas or clay. A core aerator fixes compaction; a dethatcher does not.
Many lawns have a bit of both. In that case, dethatch first, then core aerate, then overseed. Our guides on how to dethatch a lawn and how to aerate a lawn explain each step.
Choosing by Lawn Size
Small lawns under a quarter acre
A compact Sun Joe corded dethatcher is the simplest choice. It is affordable, light and easy to store, and an outlet is usually within reach.
Medium lawns
A cordless walk-behind from either brand removes cord hassle. The Sun Joe AJ805E's 15 inch path suits medium lawns if outlets are convenient, while the Craftsman V20's large bag reduces trips to empty.
Large lawns with a riding mower
Craftsman's tow-behind plug aerator and dethatcher bundle is the most efficient option, covering ground quickly and providing real core aeration.
How to Dethatch Well With Either Brand
Mow a little shorter than usual and dethatch when the soil is slightly moist and the grass is actively growing. Start on a shallow depth setting and increase gradually; aggressive settings on the first pass can rip out healthy grass. Make passes in one direction, then a second pass at an angle if thatch is heavy. Empty the bag before it gets too full. Afterwards, rake up debris, water and overseed thin areas. Our article on the importance of dethatching for lawn health explains the benefits.
Battery Platforms Matter
If you choose a cordless walk-behind, the battery platform may matter more than the dethatcher itself. Sun Joe's 24V-X2 system pairs two 24V batteries, and Sun Joe makes other 24V lawn and garden tools. CRAFTSMAN's V20 platform covers a large range of power tools and outdoor equipment, from drills to string trimmers and blowers. If you already own batteries for either system, choosing a dethatcher on that platform saves the cost of new batteries and chargers. If you own neither, think about which other tools you are likely to buy, because the battery will serve all of them.
Dethatching is demanding work for a battery. Heavy thatch, damp grass and deeper settings all reduce runtime. For a medium lawn, a spare battery or a break to recharge may be needed. Corded models avoid this entirely, which is one reason they remain popular for dethatching.
Dethatcher vs Scarifier Settings
Both brands' walk-behind machines work as dethatchers and scarifiers, but the two modes do different jobs. A dethatcher uses spring tines to comb loose thatch and moss out of the lawn. It is gentle enough for routine use. A scarifier uses rigid blades to cut into the thatch layer and the top of the soil, which is more aggressive and suits heavy thatch or renovation before overseeding.
Use the dethatcher setting for yearly maintenance, and reserve the scarifier for occasional deep work. Always start shallow, test on a small patch and increase depth only if needed.
Aftercare and Overseeding
Dethatching leaves a lawn looking thin for a short time, which is normal. Rake up and compost the debris, water deeply and overseed bare or thin patches while the soil surface is open. A light starter fertilizer helps new seedlings establish. Keep foot traffic off the lawn while it recovers. If you also core aerated, the holes give seed and fertilizer even better access to the soil.
Pros and Cons Summary
Sun Joe strengths: wide choice of walk-behind models, affordable corded options, cordless brushless kit, depth control on several models.
Sun Joe trade-offs: walk-behind only in this comparison; no core aeration.
Craftsman strengths: V20 cordless dethatcher with a large bag and foldable handle; tow-behind plug aerator and dethatcher bundles for large lawns; true core aeration with the plug aerator.
Craftsman trade-offs: only one walk-behind dethatcher option; tow tools require a riding mower or tractor.
Maintenance and Storage
Unplug corded machines or remove batteries before cleaning. Brush grass and thatch from the tines, reel housing and wheels after every use, and empty and dry the collection bag. Worn spring tines and dull scarifier blades pick up far less thatch, so inspect them each season and replace them when needed. The Craftsman V20 model's foldable handle helps with storage in tight garages, while Sun Joe's compact corded units are light enough to hang on a wall. For tow-behind tools, clean soil from coring points, check hitch pins and store with weights removed from trays.
Safety Tips
Wear eye protection, closed shoes and long pants, since dethatchers can throw debris. Keep children and pets away. Stop the motor and unplug or remove the battery before changing depth or reels or clearing clogs. With tow-behind tools, tow slowly and avoid steep or wet slopes, especially with weight in the tray.
How Often to Dethatch
Most lawns need dethatching only every one to three years. Check thatch depth each spring by cutting a small wedge of turf: if the spongy brown layer is thicker than about half an inch, it is time. Dethatching too often stresses grass without extra benefit, so let the lawn tell you when.
Signs of Compaction
If water puddles after rain, soil is hard to push a screwdriver into or grass is thin along paths, compaction is likely. That calls for core aeration rather than dethatching. Craftsman's tow plug aerator handles this on larger lawns; for smaller lawns, a manual core tool or a rented aerator works. Our guide to the best core aerator compares options.
Collection Bag Capacity
A larger collection bag, like the Craftsman V20 model's 50 litre bag, means fewer stops to empty on heavy thatch. Sun Joe's bags range from 8 gallons upward depending on model. On light thatch, either size is plenty; on heavy thatch, larger bags save time.
Corded or Cordless?
Corded dethatchers deliver steady power without runtime limits and cost less, while cordless models avoid cord management. For long dethatching sessions on medium lawns, corded power is often the more relaxed choice if outlets are nearby.
When to Dethatch
Dethatch when grass is actively growing so it recovers quickly: early spring or early fall for cool-season grasses, and late spring to early summer for warm-season grasses. Avoid dethatching during drought, heat waves or when the lawn is dormant.
Which Should You Buy?
- Best for small lawns on a budget: the Sun Joe AJ801E or AJ798E corded dethatcher.
- Best walk-behind for medium lawns: the Sun Joe AJ805E 15 inch.
- Best cordless for Sun Joe 24V owners: the 24V-X2-DTS15 or tool-only CT version.
- Best cordless for CRAFTSMAN V20 owners: the Craftsman 2x V20 brushless dethatcher.
- Best for large lawns with a riding mower: the Craftsman 40 inch tow plug aerator and dethatcher bundle.
For more options, see our guides to the best electric aerator and the best lawn aerator.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Sun Joe and Craftsman lawn tools?
Sun Joe focuses on walk-behind electric dethatchers and scarifiers, both corded and cordless. Craftsman offers a cordless V20 dethatcher plus tow-behind plug aerators, spike aerators, dethatchers and spreaders for riding mower owners.
Is the Craftsman V20 dethatcher cordless?
Yes. It runs on two V20 batteries, with a brushless motor, a 14 inch deck, a 50 litre collection bag and up to about 45 minutes of runtime per the listing.
Do Sun Joe dethatchers aerate the lawn?
They slice and rake the surface, which helps air and water reach the soil, but they do not remove soil plugs like a core aerator.
Which is better for a large lawn?
For large lawns with a riding mower, Craftsman's tow-behind plug aerator and dethatcher cover ground much faster than any walk-behind machine.
Which is better for a small lawn?
A compact Sun Joe corded dethatcher is an affordable, easy-to-store option for small lawns near an outlet.







